Flying club vs. flight school near NYC
How flying clubs and flight schools compare on cost, trips, and availability.
Overview
If you want to rent a plane near NYC, several airports near the city have flight schools and flying clubs with Cessna 172s and other aircraft.
Joining a flying club and renting from a flight school differ in a few important ways:
- A club usually charges “wet tach” rather than “wet Hobbs”, which results in significantly cheaper flight hours.
- Clubs (including Richmond Pilots) allow for multi-day trips with advance planning.
- Flight schools have no upfront cost, but significantly higher hourly aircraft rates.
- Depending on the school, there may be more options for types of aircraft and better availability for instructors.
Paying tach vs. Hobbs
Flight schools around NYC typically charge a “wet Hobbs” rate. Wet rates include fuel, and the Hobbs meter is a clock that runs whenever the engine is running.
In contrast, most flying clubs charge a “wet tach” rate. Similarly, fuel is included, but the tach meter counts engine revolutions and runs more slowly at lower RPMs, such as during taxi and descent.
On a typical flight in the club’s aircraft, the tach records about 75% of the time the Hobbs does. The gap is biggest on lessons and pattern work, with lots of time at low power, and smallest on a long cruise. Around NYC, time spent taxiing and waiting for takeoff adds up quickly, and on a Hobbs rate you pay for all of it.
That makes hourly rates hard to compare directly. To compare like with like, here is the club’s tach rate converted into an estimated cost per Hobbs hour, next to typical rental rates for the same models nearby.
| Aircraft | Flight School, Hobbs Rate | Richmond Pilots Tach Rates | Richmond Pilots Hobbs Rates (est.) | Club saving |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cessna 172M | $200 | $150 | $113 | 44% |
| Cessna 172S | $250 | $165 | $124 | 51% |
Typical rental rates are based on wet rates published by flight schools near NYC, checked November 2026. The club estimate assumes 75% tach time per Hobbs hour.
Flying the club’s aircraft costs 44–51% less than a typical rental of the same model nearby.
Costs for a real flight
| Flight | Hobbs | Tach (est.) | Flight School | Richmond Pilots |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hudson River corridor sightseeing flight | 1.0 hours | 0.8 hours | $250 | $124 |
| Instrument practice, a few approaches nearby | 1.5 hours | 1.1 hours | $375 | $186 |
| Lunch on Block Island (KBID) and back | 2.5 hours | 1.9 hours | $625 | $309 |
Costs for a Cessna 172S: Richmond Pilots at $165 per tach hour, a flight school at $250 per Hobbs hour.
Multi-day trips
Few flight schools will allow for multi-day trips using their aircraft. At flying clubs like Richmond Pilots, it’s the norm. Our members often take the plane for the weekend to places like North Carolina, Martha’s Vineyard, or AirVenture in Oshkosh, Wisconsin.

Flying clubs handle multi-day trips differently, but at Richmond Pilots there is no daily minimum and you only pay for the hours you actually fly (e.g., if the plane sits for two days, you do not pay extra for that).
Flight school pros
As an honest counterpoint, there are lots of good reasons to rent from flight schools:
- No waitlists: Flying clubs typically have waitlists that rely on members leaving. Sometimes the waitlist is empty; other times it can take several months.
- No upfront fee: Part 61 flight schools have no admission fee, deposit, or monthly dues.
- More variety: Flight schools may have a larger fleet and a wider variety of aircraft to fly.
- More instructors: Richmond Pilots has club CFIs, but flight schools are likely to have a larger number of CFIs available.
- Less responsibility: No club meetings, plane washes, or additional costs.
Flying club benefits aside from cost and availability
Flying clubs are a great way to join a group of pilots to co-own aircraft. As a result, you meet new people to fly with and gain a deeper understanding of aircraft maintenance.
Aircraft availability is usually higher with flying clubs because the membership is fixed.
Our monthly meetings are a great way to stay informed about aircraft maintenance, club finances, and other ongoing matters, and to keep learning through safety presentations from the chief pilot.
Becoming a member
We encourage all prospective members to join us for our monthly meeting:
- Who
- Pilots (active and retired), Members, Prospective Members and Guests
- When
- 2nd Tuesday of the month at 7:30 pm
- Where
- Panini Grill in Staten Island, NY
When you’re ready to apply, fill out the Membership Application, email it to contact@richmondpilots.org, and bring the $100 deposit to a monthly meeting. See Become a Member for how the waitlist works.
